Strommasten im Nebel

What Should the Electricity Market Design of the Future Look Like?

The growing share of renewable energy in the German electricity mix is good for climate protection but poses challenges for the electricity system. In September 2024, the German Chamber of Commerce and Industry (DIHK) provided an assessment of the federal economics ministry's proposals for electricity market design.

For its consultation on 'Electricity Market Design of the Future', the Federal Ministry of Economics asked the associations for an assessment. In its statement, the DIHK largely advocates for the market-driven expansion of renewables. The electricity market offers sufficient security options for investors.

In its statement, the DIHK largely advocates for the market-driven expansion of renewables. The electricity market offers sufficient security options for investors. Furthermore, DIHK considers the options submitted by the federal economics ministry too complex and suggests a simpler, implementable model that reduces bureaucracy, enables market signals, and offers subsidies for a transitional period. The proposed capacity mechanism is viewed critically by DIHK.

Avoiding Complexity and Mismanagement

Key Statements at a Glance

  • Market-driven expansion of renewable energies is possible, while overemphasis on funding needs causes distortions.
  • A simple and limited investment premium is preferred as a transitional tool.
  • Forward and PPA markets are key hedging instruments and should not be displaced by state guarantees.
  • Contracts for differences weaken market price signals and the function of the German forward market as a "lead currency."
  • Central capacity markets and combined models increase complexity, costs, and the risk of mismanagement and overdimensioning.
  • If capacity mechanisms are introduced, they should be embedded at a European level; national solo approaches and lengthy aid procedures jeopardize planning certainty.
  • Simple, quickly implementable solutions with minimal bureaucracy are preferable; market signals should dictate the plant configuration.
  • Operating cost subsidies with repayment obligations increase risks and bid costs; investment grants avoid this.

Download

You can find the entire DIHK statement, including numerous other detailed assessments of the future electricity market design, here:

Electricity Market Design of the Future (PDF, 2 MB) (only available in German)

The underlying document is available on the Federal Ministry of Economics website.

Relevant in topic:

Ansprechpartner

Wenz, Niclas

Dr. Niclas Wenz

Head of Unit for Electricity Market, Renewable Energy and National Climate Protection

Löffelholz, Julia_test

Julia Löffelholz

Spokesperson